{"kind":"RECORDED_RESEARCH_MATERIAL_CLIENT_CHECKS","checked_on":"2026-10-02","case":"Defensive Log4Shell research using the official Apache advisory","fixture_notice":"Inventory, image, SBOM, log and browser text are hypothetical; not evidence of a real incident","source_url":"https://logging.apache.org/security.html","results":[{"client":"Cursor CLI","status":"PASS","role":"researcher","seconds":103,"required_tools":["evidence.get","evidence.locate","evidence.view","extract_json","finding.create","research.export_stix"],"missing_tools":[],"trace":[{"tool":"identity.whoami","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"capabilities.describe","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"campaign.join","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"task.claim","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.locate","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"extract_json","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"fetch_text","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.view","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.view","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"research.export_stix","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"fetch_snapshot","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"fetch_snapshot","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"finding.create","status":"COMPLETED"}]},{"client":"Codex CLI 0.150.1, GPT-5.5","status":"PASS","role":"independent reviewer","seconds":133,"required_tools":["evidence.get","evidence.locate","evidence.view","extract_json","finding.review","research.export_stix"],"missing_tools":[],"trace":[{"tool":"identity.whoami","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"capabilities.describe","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"campaign.join","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"task.claim","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.view","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.view","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.locate","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"extract_json","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"research.export_stix","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"finding.list","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"finding.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"evidence.get","status":"COMPLETED"},{"tool":"finding.review","status":"COMPLETED"}]}],"checks":{"independent_reviews":1,"official_server_sources":1,"owner_imports":5},"limits":["PASS means the required tool workflow completed, not that every conclusion was certified.","Five imported inventory, PDF/image, SBOM, log and browser materials are hypothetical and UNVERIFIED, not evidence of an actual incident.","The reviewer received saved findings and evidence IDs, not the first agent conversation.","Native PDF/PNG image calls completed in both clients; Codex reported no extra pixel analysis.","This research run used short-lived bearer connections, not a new native OAuth renewal test.","The separate Grok CLI attempt required a new sign-in; Claude Code reported that subscription access was disabled by the organisation.","No host scanning, exploit execution or new client-login workaround was performed."]}